An inquiry into the principles of the distribution of wealth by William Thompson

By William Thompson

William Thompson (1775 – 28 March 1833) was once an Irish political and philosophical author and social reformer, constructing from utilitarianism into an early critic of capitalist exploitation whose rules encouraged the Cooperative, exchange Union and Chartist activities in addition to Karl Marx. Born into the Anglo-Irish Ascendancy of rich landowners and retailers of Cork society, his try to will his property to the cooperative circulate after his dying sparked a protracted courtroom case as his kinfolk fought effectively to have the desire annulled. in line with E. T. Craig, this determination to will his property to the cooperative circulate used to be taken after a trip to the pioneering Ralahine Commune. Marxist James Connolly defined him because the "first Irish socialist" and a forerunner to Marx.

An enthusiastic scholar of the writers and concepts of the Enlightenment, really Condorcet, Thompson turned a confident egalitarian and democrat. His aid for the French Revolution earned him the label of "Red Republican" from Cork society and his help for advocates of Catholic emancipation in elections extra alienated him from the remainder of his filthy rich Protestant kith and kin.

Thompson used to be significantly inspired by way of the utilitarianism of Jeremy Bentham, with whom he corresponded and demonstrated a friendship, later staying on the English philosopher's apartment for a number of months in 1821–22 whereas traveling London. in addition to Bentham, Thompson learn and corresponded with different utilitarian contemporaries reminiscent of James Mill, and used to be inspired, either absolutely and negatively, by means of William Godwin and Thomas Malthus. His wish to triumph over the restrictions of Godwin's "intellectual speculations" and Malthus's "mechanical speculations" led him to suggest a brand new synthesis: social technology – Thompson was once the 1st to introduce this time period – which might mix political economy's obstacle with clinical materialism with utilitarianism's crisis with rational morality.

It was once the contrasting rules of Godwin and Malthus that spurred Thompson into the undertaking of analysis into the function of distribution in political economic climate that led him to London and, in 1824, this book, "An inquiry into the foundations of the distribution of wealth such a lot conducive to human happiness; utilized to the newly proposed approach of voluntary equality of wealth". Thompson had additionally turn into accustomed to the paintings of the French utopian socialists together with Charles Fourier, Henri Saint-Simon, and the economist Sismondi.

In the Inquiry, Thompson follows the road of the labour thought of worth recommend through Adam Smith. besides the fact that he characterizes the appropriation of the lion's percentage of surplus price by means of the capitalist proprietor of the instruments of construction as exploitation. He rejects the Malthus/Mill proposition that any elevate within the salary of the employees can basically bring about their additional immiseration, noting the self-serving nature of this conception for capitalists urgent for laws to outlaw staff efforts to elevate their wages. via making use of the utilitarian precept of "the maximum stable for the best quantity" to the prevailing and attainable substitute schemes of distribution, Thompson comes down at the aspect of an egalitarian distribution of the product.

One of Thompson's colleagues within the Cooperative flow, John Minter Morgan, made the commentary that he used to be the 1st to coin the time period aggressive to explain the prevailing financial system. The case for the originality of this paintings is extra made through Max Nettlau who states: "[Thompson's] booklet, besides the fact that, discloses his personal evolution; having begun with a requirement for the complete made from labour in addition to the legislation of distribution, he ended up along with his personal conversion to communism, that's, limitless distribution."

In 1827 fellow "Ricardian socialist" Thomas Hodgskin released Labour Defended which additionally characterized the appropriation of the lion's percentage of the end result of creation via landlord and capitalist as exploitation defrauding the employee of the total manufactured from their labour. besides the fact that, Hodgskin proposed that the line to monetary justice for the labourer used to be via a reformed aggressive method. Thompson answered with hard work Rewarded protecting cooperative communism opposed to Hodgskin's unequal wages.

Although he rejected the political and monetary implications of Malthus' essay on inhabitants, Thompson acknowledged that, relatively in eire, unrestrained inhabitants development did pose the specter of emerging poverty. As such he used to be like Bentham and Francis position an suggest of some great benefits of birth control. Thompson's improvement of a critique of the modern prestige of ladies used to be so much strongly motivated via his long term shut friendship with Anna Wheeler. He had met Wheeler whereas staying with Bentham they usually moved in these utilitarian circles that integrated James Mill. It was once the e-book of the latter's "On executive" which known as for the vote for males purely, that aroused the fervent competition of either Wheeler and Thompson and to the rebuttal in "Appeal of 1 part the Human Race...".

Thompson and others of the Cooperative stream have tended to be a bit of unfairly subsumed less than the political label of Owenism. in reality, even supposing his writings and social experiments at New Lanark had helped to carry the cooperative flow jointly, many, Thompson incorporated, have been serious of Owen's authoritarian and anti-democratic developments. Thompson additional distrusted Owen's courtship of wealthy and robust buyers, believing that the wealthy as a category may perhaps by no means be anticipated to be in favour of any undertaking of emancipation for the labouring negative as this could threaten their privilege. He additionally believed within the necessity of the staff in any co-operative group having eventual protection of possession of the community's land and capital estate. He won a substantial following in the cooperative flow for those positions and it was once to differentiate themselves from Owen's positions that this wing of the stream started to undertake the label of "socialist or communionist" (Letter to "The Cooperative Magazine", London, November 1827, brought up through OED as first documented use of socialist) instead of "Owenist".

These transformations ended in open war of words among Thompson and Owen on the 3rd Cooperative Congress held in 1832 in London. Owen, might be discouraged through the failure of his tried group at New concord, maintained that it used to be essential to look forward to executive and inventory alternate aid and funding into huge scale groups. Thompson and his supporters contended that they need to circulate in the direction of developing autonomous small scale groups according to the movement's personal assets. The argument used to be no longer resolved at that congress and by way of the next one Thompson was once not able to wait most likely a result of affliction that was once to guide to his demise in one other 5 months.

Karl Marx had encounter Thompson's paintings on a trip to Manchester in 1845, and cites it in passing within the Poverty of Philosophy (1847), and likewise in Capital itself. although, an identical will be acknowledged of alternative of the proto-socialist political economists, akin to Thomas Hodgskin, John grey, and John Francis Bray. it sort of feels fantastic then, that the likes of Beatrice and Sidney Webb could characterise Marx as "the illustrious disciple" of Thompson and Hodgskin. Sentiments additionally echoed through the likes of Harold Laski and different British historians of socialism. during this they have been accepting the sooner thesis in Anton Menger's correct to the full Produce of Labour (1899), amalgamating all of the aforementioned right into a homogeneous classification of Ricardian socialists which obscured the real variations among Thompson's communist critique of Hodgskin's "market libertarian" position.

Born in Cork, William used to be the son and inheritor of 1 of the main wealthy retailers of that urban, Alderman John Thompson, who held, among different workplaces, that of Mayor in 1794. William inherited the small buying and selling fleet and landed property close to Glandore, West Cork after his father's demise in 1814. Rejecting the position of absentee landlord often led by way of these of the same scenario, William dependent his dwelling quarters at the property and regardless of many travels, invested a lot time with the tenants at the property introducing agricultural options, prone and schooling for kids aimed toward enhancing the welfare and prosperity of the households present.

Victim of vulnerable future health from an early age, Thompson grew to become a non-smoker, teetotaller and vegetarian for the final thirteen years of his existence. those abstemious conduct, he defined, helped him to pay attention to his examining and writing. still, by way of the 1830s, he was once being affected by a chest disorder that at last killed him on 28 March 1833. He had by no means married and left no direct inheritor.

Show description

Read Online or Download An inquiry into the principles of the distribution of wealth most conducive to human happiness; applied to the newly proposed system of voluntary equality of wealth PDF

Best history & theory books

Nietzsche and Legal Theory: Half-Written Laws (Discourses of Law)

"Nietzsche and felony conception" is an anthology designed to supply felony and socio-legal students with a feeling of the very wide variety of tasks and questions in whose pursuit Nietsche's paintings should be priceless. From clinical ethics to criminology, from the systemic anti-Semitism of criminal codes bobbing up in Christian cultures, to the main points of highbrow estate debates approximately regulating using culturally major items, the participants (from the fields of legislations, philosophy, criminology, cultural experiences, and literary stories) exhibit and enact this type of creativity that Nietzsche linked to the free-spirits to whom he addressed a few of his most important paintings.

Antonio Gramsci: Selections from Political Writings 1921-1926

Notwithstanding he died as Benito Mussolini's prisoner, leaving in simple terms newspaper articles and fragmentary notes, Antonio Gramsci is now noticeable because the most important Marxist philosopher because Lenin. This quantity is the 1st English translation of his writings on tradition, organically and coherently edited from his journalism and his criminal Notebooks.

Sozialismus: Theorien des Sozialismus, Anarchismus und Kommunismus im Zeitalter der Ideologien 1789 – 1945

Sozialistische und kommunistische Theorien entwickelten sich in Europa seit Babeuf in der Französischen Revolution. Varianten sozialistischer Theoretiker im Kommunismus, Anarchismus und Sozialdemokratismus bekämpften einander erbittert in allen europäischen Ländern von Spanien bis Russland. In diesem Band werden die Hauptformen sozialistischer und kommunistischer Parteien bis hin zu den „Internationalen“ in Beziehung zu den herausragenden Denkern der Linken gesetzt.

The General Will: The Evolution of a Concept

Even though it originated in theological debates, the overall will eventually grew to become the most celebrated and denigrated innovations rising from early sleek political inspiration. Jean-Jacques Rousseau made it the vital portion of his political conception, and it took on a lifetime of its personal in the course of the French Revolution, earlier than being subjected to generations of include or opprobrium.

Additional resources for An inquiry into the principles of the distribution of wealth most conducive to human happiness; applied to the newly proposed system of voluntary equality of wealth

Example text

Consistently with this principle, if the slavery of nine out of ten and the superlative happiness of the tenth increased the sum total of happiness, that distribuAll that is asked by tion, of slavery, should be pursued. this first principle, is, that the greatest quantity of agreeable sensations, both in intensity and duration, should be the obaimed at in the distribution of wealth. To deny it, would be to affirm that pain is to be preferred to pleasure, that no sensations are preferable to agreeable ones, that not feeling, which is tantamount to non-existence, is to be preferred to feeling or existence.

INVESTIGATION OF THE NATURAL PRINCIPLES, RULES, OR LAWS, ON WHICH ALL JUST DISTRIBUTION OF WEALTH OUGHT TO BE FOUNDED DEDUCED FROM OUR ORGANIZATION, AND THE CIRCUMSTANCES, PHYSICAL AND SOCIAL, WHICH SURROUND US. I UTILITY^ calculating all effects, good and evil, immediate and remote, or the pursuit of the greatest possible sum of human happiness, is the leading principle constantly kept in and to which all others are but subsidiary, in this inquiry. In Bentham's " Introduction to the Principles of Morals and " Traites Legislation^* and the first chapters of the celebrated view, de Legislation," this principle, recognised by Helvetius, Priestley, Paley, and others, is developed and established for ever, to the exclusion of all other pretended tests of morals.

SECTION 9. The forced abstraction of small portions of wealth from any given number of individuals, will lessen the whole quantity of happiness more than it can be increased by the additional pleasures conferred on any one or more individuals enjoying these united small forced masses. Therefore, tlxe^H^uce^jpf-J^^ nor the labor itself, nor any part of them, should be taken from the laborer, without an equivalent by him deemed satisfactory. SECTION 11. The materials of wealth should be so distri- buted as to accomplish the double object of promoting the utmost possible equality of enjoyment and the utmost possible proouctlon maTTs to say, to promote the utmost " consistent with secupossible equality of distribution ; development of every useful human and intellectual, and of course of the energy, physical production of wealth, depending on the degree of security rity ;" the degree of enjoyed.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.56 of 5 – based on 43 votes